THE PORT OF LAST RESORT
During World War II, there seemed no hope for millions of European Jews running from the horrors of the Holocaust. But one city offered sanctuary to all - Shanghai. This little known story of survival in the intriguing international settlement is retold in a gripping new documentary.
By Ron Gluckman /Hong Kong and Shanghai
THE GRAINY BLACK-AND-WHITE footage of a young girl waving on a cruise ship could be from any holiday film unearthed in a family attic. Mom is leaning on a boat railing, in mock embarrassment as she shoos away papa, who is gleefully using his latest toy, a brand-new 8 mm camera.
But the footage is no typical home movie, and this is no ordinary cruise. The family is among a small group of lucky survivors, European Jews sailing to Shanghai, and freedom from the Nazi holocaust. The scratchy footage is the opening gem of a remarkable new film, "The Port of Last Resort."
Produced by Austrian Paul Rosdy and American Joan Grossman, the gripping 79-minute documentary about the Shanghai shelter for thousands of European Jews has already created a stir in Europe, where it was released a few months ago in German. An English version had much the same reaction during its Asian premier at the Hong Kong Film Festival last week.
In this era of "Schindler's List" and "Life is Beautiful," there seems to be no end to the public appetite for new material about the Holocaust, which claimed the lives of six million Jews and millions more gypsies and non-Aryans. At the same time, historians wonder whether there is really anything of significance left to say about a half-century old tragedy.
This makes "The Port of Last Resort" all the more remarkable. Using never-before seen home movies, letters from refuges and archival footage, the understated film successfully takes a new look at an old story, focusing on one small chapter in the Holocaust annals: the escape to Shanghai, where nearly 20,000 European Jews not only survived, but created an unique community. The reason? Shanghai was the freest city in the world, offering no entry requirements at a time when other possible havens for refugees were shutting down.
"This is a little-known, and amazing story," says Grossman, who grew up in Indianapolis. A pair of family friends were Jewish survivors from Shanghai, and one of them, Ernest G. Heppner, recently published his memoirs. Grossman was enchanted, not only by the themes of hardship and accomplishment, but also the legacy of this magical wartime community.
"There is a lot of trendiness to the subject," admits Grossman, 39, who is Jewish. Rosdy, 35, is non-Jewish, but he also found a special connection to the story. "I had read a lot about Austria and what happened to the Jews in World War II, but really, it seemed that everything had been done. This was a chance to tell the story in a new way, by looking at one layer of the entire story."
It was a challenging and time-consuming project for two filmmakers with no major experience. Financial support came from Austrian arts funds, and HBO, which will be airing "The Port of Last Resort" on a specialty channel. Rosdy and Grossman also hope to release the documentary - shot on expensive 35mm film rather than video - at festivals and in limited showing at art cinemas.
The pair spent four full years chasing research material in three continents. Rosdy combed archives in Germany and Austria, while Grossman worked collections in America, where many Jews from Shanghai wound up after the mass exodus from China that followed the communist takeover in 1949.
"We went through thousands of documents," says Rosdy. "There was so much material, all over the world, different pieces, here and there. It was a real puzzle to put this all together." In the end, the filmmakers focused on the stories of four survivors: Heppner and his wife, Illo, who were married in Shanghai, Fred Fields and Siegmar Simon. Present-day interviews with these four are intertwined with extraordinary images of Shanghai in the 1930s and 1940s. The film includes a rich vein of research material, backed by evocative period tunes plus an original score by the renowned John Zorn. Intimacy is added in actual letters from refugees to friends and family back home. The simple structure enhances the impact of the story. One gets chills hearing a refugee tell how none of the Jews in Shanghai even knew about the Holocaust until the war was over.
To be sure, there were hardships aplenty in Shanghai, where the influx of tens of thousands of impoverished refugees overwhelmed the abilities of the existing Jewish community, as well as the ruling Japanese, who eventually herded them into the Hongkew ghetto. Food was scarce and survivors vividly describe suffering through the bitter Shanghai winter in rags and homemade sandals. Unlike in Europe, though, the Jews in Shanghai's ghetto fared no worse than the population around them. And there was no policy of repression or genocide.
Quite to the contrary, the Jews flourished in Shanghai for a time. They opened so many German bakeries and Austrian coffee houses, one area of town was dubbed Little Vienna. Jewish musicians from Europe dominated the Shanghai symphony, and soon there were theatrical productions and newspapers in a myriad of languages including German, Russian, Polish and Yiddish.
"The Port of Last Resort" also depicts the mesmerizing qualities of one of Asia’s most magical cities. One refugee recalls: "Shanghai was a fake, a phony, neither occidental nor oriental. And yet—God forgive me—she was the most exciting and unique city in the world." Yet the film wisely never veers from its tight focus on intriguing stories of escape and survival.
"Shanghai was a waiting station. That's really what makes it unique," Rosdy says. "No one planned to stay there. They just had no other options, so they went and that's what made them so lucky. They survived, not like the Jews of Europe. That's what makes this a different story. It's a story of survival."
Ron Gluckman is an American reporter who is based in Hong Kong, but who roams around Asia for a number of publications, such as the Wall Street Journal, which ran this story in April 1999. Be sure and return to the index for other stories about the intriguing Jewish community that flourished in Shanghai before World War II.
Picture from historical archives.
To return to the opening page and index